The number of natural attenuation field assessments
has expanded over the past few years. Of note are the natural attenuation field
characterization studies completed by AFCEE for fuel hydrocarbons and chlorinated
solvent sites (Wiedemeier et al. 1995 and 1997). These studies provide the
most comprehensive database of geochemical characterization collected in support
of natural attenuation currently available. Other studies include Barker et
al. (1987), Klecka et al. (1990), Caldwell et al. (1992), Borden et al. (1994),
McAllister and Chiang (1994), Stauffer et al. (1994), Rifai and Bedient (1994),
Davis et al. (1994), Daniel (1995), Wilson et al. (1995), and Wiedemeier and
Chapelle (2000).
The numerous studies listed above as well as additional
case studies presented at the Battelle Conference series on In Situ and On Site
Bioremediation (Battelle, 1991, 1993, 1995, and 1997) all demonstrate a number
of common themes about Natural Attenuation:
- Natural attenuation processes have been observed and documented
at numerous sites;
- Natural attenuation controls the extent of migration of
contaminants away from the source and limits the extent of the dissolved plume;
- Intrinsic bioremediation of fuel hydrocarbons in groundwater
occurs universally and many of these plumes
are stable or shrinking, while only some sites contaminated with chlorinated
solvents exhibit intrinsic bioremediation;
- Geochemical characterization of the groundwater provides
ample data for quantifying the natural attenuation processes that may be important
at a given site;
- Biodegradation is one of the most important attenuation
mechanisms that contributes to declines in contaminant concentration and loss
of mass in almost all fuel hydrocarbon plumes and in some chlorinated solvent
plumes;
- Aerobic biodegradation of fuel hydrocarbons is evidenced
by depletion of dissolved oxygen inside the plume;
- Anaerobic biodegradation of fuel hydrocarbons is evidenced
by depletion of nitrate and sulfate and production of dissolved iron (Fe[II])
and methane inside the plume;
- Anaerobic biodegradation processes, while slower than
aerobic biodegradation, are a significant component of natural attenuation
due to the abundance of anaerobic electron acceptors (NO3-1,
Fe(III), Mn, SO4-2 and CO2) relative to dissolved
oxygen (see data from the Air Force sites in Appendix A).
- While some chlorinated solvents (e.g., DCA) will degrade
aerobically, and most will biodegrade during cometabolism, halorespiration
is the most important biodegradation reaction involving the common chlorinated
solvents. In this reaction electron donors such as BTEX and methanol are fermented
to form the direct electron donor, dissolved hydrogen. Halorespirators then
use the hydrogen to dechlorinate the chlorinated solvents.
- Halorespiration is indicated by: (i) dissolved hydrogen
concentrations in certain ranges; (ii) low reduction/oxidation (redox) potential
environments from which electron acceptors such as sulfate have been removed;
(iii) the presence of methane, which indicates the presence of fermentation
reactions and hydrogen; and (iv) the presence of biologically produced daughter
products that are not typically released at given sites, such as cis-1,2-dichoroethene
(DCE) and VC.
|